I doubt their responses would be any different than Irock's. i.e. they'll just give us statistics and features and pros to try and outweigh the cons, without giving any real argument.

So why don't you just find out already? All you're doing is sitting around here saying what you think they'd say instead of actually going to them and telling them why you think Stencyl won't succeed. I mean, come on.

lol I'm actually just aggravating Irock. I actually don't know anything about Stencyl. He knows it's in good fun.














OR IS IT?













WHAT I DO KNOW IS THIS:

1.Stencyl is limited to fan games.

2.Stencyl sucks.

3.Irock has a foul odor emitting from his mouthal area.

4.There is no number 4.

5.Jon doesn't understand snippets will cause many compatibility issues.

6.Stencyl will never be popular.

8|

Also, if i get about 10 people with me i'd join the forums with them and then there'd be 10 critisizers.

Jon would love that.

Jon loves everything.

yay halo understands the compatibility problem.

Irock, stencyl is limited to fan games.
I know that JON won't provide any extra resources but the ones in the "Jumperman" pack and all.
just ask JON to provide extra resources too. Then it'll suck less.
And i'm capitalizing JON cuz i like the name and not because i hate him.

Mind cutting down on the non-seriousness? This isn't The Sewers. ~_~

Stencyl isn't limited to fan games >_> Unless your imagination is that incapable then yes.

Quote from: Dan80315 on April 02, 2008, 11:49:23 AM
Stencyl isn't limited to fan games >_> Unless your imagination is that incapable then yes.

In that case your mind is limited to creating fan games, not the program itself.

Exactly what he just said. lol

There, i asked them.


lets wait and watch~
and no, irock. let jon and all answer this

Quote from: Nightwolf on April 10, 2008, 04:33:11 PM
There, i asked them.


lets wait and watch~
and no, irock. let jon and all answer this

And you got the official answer. >:3

Stop deleting my posts, i'm stating that there is no evidence that stencyl doesn't seem limited to fan games.

Quote from: Anski on April 10, 2008, 10:38:50 PM
Stop deleting my posts, i'm stating that there is no evidence that stencyl doesn't seem limited to fan games.

You're not posting serious posts, and something seeming some way is a matter of opinion.

Quote from: Irock on April 10, 2008, 11:11:53 PM

Quote from: Anski on April 10, 2008, 10:38:50 PM
Stop deleting my posts, i'm stating that there is no evidence that stencyl doesn't seem limited to fan games.

You're not posting serious posts, and something seeming some way is a matter of opinion.

/facepalm

I'm saying that your evidence has not proved to me that Stencyl will be capable of making quality original games that are not breaking a copyright intellectual license.

It seems Stencyl is limited to fan games. We have evidence to prove this:

All examples explaining or demonstrating Stencyl are fan games.

Evidence against it:

... "Stencyl can be used to make any 2D game. We will give you generic resources!"

Quote from: Anski on April 10, 2008, 11:15:41 PM

Quote from: Irock on April 10, 2008, 11:11:53 PM

Quote from: Anski on April 10, 2008, 10:38:50 PM
Stop deleting my posts, i'm stating that there is no evidence that stencyl doesn't seem limited to fan games.

You're not posting serious posts, and something seeming some way is a matter of opinion.

/facepalm

I'm saying that your evidence has not proved to me that Stencyl will be capable of making quality original games that are not breaking a copyright intellectual license.

Besides them saying that you can import your custom resources and create your game's features from the ground up. I'm sure we shouldn't believe them at all. They're probably lying to us to ruin their reputation when Stencyl is actually out, if it ever DOES come out. Hell they could be lying about the whole thing. If a game developer announces that the main character will have a sword, we shouldn't believe him, unless the game is already out. The game developer could actually be lying for no reason at all!

Quote from: Irock on April 10, 2008, 11:20:45 PM

Quote from: Anski on April 10, 2008, 11:15:41 PM

Quote from: Irock on April 10, 2008, 11:11:53 PM

Quote from: Anski on April 10, 2008, 10:38:50 PM
Stop deleting my posts, i'm stating that there is no evidence that stencyl doesn't seem limited to fan games.

You're not posting serious posts, and something seeming some way is a matter of opinion.

/facepalm

I'm saying that your evidence has not proved to me that Stencyl will be capable of making quality original games that are not breaking a copyright intellectual license.

Besides them saying that you can import your custom resources and create your game's features from the ground up. I'm sure we shouldn't believe them at all. They're probably lying to us to ruin their reputation when Stencyl is actually out, if it ever DOES come out. Hell they could be lying about the whole thing. If a game developer announces that the main character will have a sword, we shouldn't believe him, unless the game is already out. The game developer could actually be lying for no reason at all!

Exactly.

Topic served it's purpose.

o'rly?

Too much hype. Stencyl might turn out to be a good program, but it's not going to be anywhere near the godliness they all make it out to be.

The forum says it has a program where member make resources and they won't be provinding many resources besides the kits.


also

Stencyl seems limited to fan games doesn't it?

We can't argue whether or not Stencyl seems limited to fan games, because that's a matter of opinion. The fact is, according to the Stencyl team, Stencyl isn't limited to fangames, since you can import your own graphics and define how the game functions. Sure, they could be lying about it all, but there's no way to argue about that either, since you can't prove them right or wrong. The only thing we really have to go by is their word. I'm simply reporting on what they have said.

Quote from: NightwolfThe forum says it has a program where member make resources

They plan to create a site/area for resources, called StencylForge.

Quote from: Nightwolfthey won't be provinding many resources besides the kits.

I believe Jon said, "There will be some generic resources that are suitable for acting as placeholders for games. Of course, it's not recommended that you ship your game with them since it'd look too generic." He never commented on the amount of resources they would include.

Also, there's a new topic in the FAQs.

some.

And why cant we ship them. I dun see anything wrong with a "rtp" style game

Quote from: Irock on April 13, 2008, 06:20:51 PM
"There will be some generic resources that are suitable for acting as placeholders for games. Of course, it's not recommended that you ship your game with them since it'd look too generic." He never commented on the amount of resources they would include.

It's not recommended that you use the program for what it's been advertised to do?