Give the person ^ you a present

[Daniel Otterbach]

Gives ^ a similar shirt. 

[tSwitch]

repays ^ for the killer shirt

[Daniel Otterbach]

Gives ^ an even cooler and slightly familiar shirt. 

[spoiler][/spoiler]

[tSwitch]

blinks a few times at the shirt and gives ^ some oysters

[tSwitch]

gives ^  a supermarket tileset

[Kathryn]

gives /\ a funny(ish) yet oddly metaphorical siggy.

[Zylos]

Gives /\ a kiss, then gives \/ a kiss too.

[tSwitch]

blushes and gives ^ a book entitled "How to NOT rush an ending"

[Daniel Otterbach]

Gives ^ positive rep. I can't think of anything else to give. 

[Zylos]

Gives /\ a fish.

[The Shadow]

Gives /\ a brand new car.

[Zylos]

Gives /\ the title of "mapping king".

[The Shadow]

Gives /\  a piece of land in Sweden.

[Zylos]

Gives /\ a "massage".

[Daniel Otterbach]

Gives ^ a collar with a little tag that says "Zylos" on it. 

[Kathryn]

gives /\ that shirt.

you know which one.

[CartoonFan]

Gives ^ a loaded FN-P90.

[Kathryn]

/\ sorry animefan, i'm not joining your army.

i shall give you a zylos's pancake house coupon.

[CartoonFan]

^ Was not my goal.

Gives you  ...
and eggs.

[Nightwolf]

Gives ^ Book called "How to get rid of anime fetish" written by the famous- Iluvh Entai

[Zylos]

Gives /\ a fox treat.

[Daniel Otterbach]

Gives /\ a fox treat.

[Zylos]

Gives /\ an otter treat.

[Nightwolf]

Gives ^ a wolf costume

[Kathryn]

Gives /\ A free coupon booklet for random therapists,(free with every support group membership : O)