His argument would only apply given that the Atheist actually pormoted Atheism, which I highly doubt.
Also, who really cares? It sounds like a joke. Rodriguez needs to lighten up.
Also, I'm not quite sure why she says it's not a joke, they did it because she was an atheist. Isn't that the whole point of the joke? It wouldn't really make any sense to dump holy water on a theist?
Meh.