And just so I'm clear, I am saving this as a 256 color PNG. It is flat, 1 layer. No transparency, though that shouldn't be a problem anyway. There is NO REASON this should not be working.
Even when I try saving it as a 256 color BMP, it still says INVALID COLOR DEPTH.
The insane thing is that if I take another of my charsets, it's uploads fine, but if I copy that working charset and paste THIS one one top of it, and then save it with the same settings, it is no longer compatible. What. The. Fuck.
This program is being such a faggot.