Story: You story isn't really detailed. That really nothing going for it. Is there an epic quest, or is it more of an exploring game. You characters are't very developed and some are cliched. It seems like you are trying to fit your characters in the game, not have the game fit the characters. The story can go two ways, as you are on the edge right now with you story. Please dont make this a cliche nightmare, use originality to create a emotional journey. (:
Graphics: Well, your mapping needs work. You misuse tiles and overall its dull and boring. In a town as big as that, I expect load of people, not just a person here and there. Shrink your maps down, move the buildings closer together, and add more detail. (:
Other Notes: Some of your features, I wouldn't call features such as the story update and the gambling. To tell you truth, this looks like your first project. With dedication and a lot of work, this could be a good game, but you need to get it to that point. (: