Ok, seriously guys. I took a look through this list ->
http://gamelist.mmosite.com/area/US.html Every single MMO says, "We're completely revolutionary and stuff like that." EVERY SINGLE MMORPG IS THE SAME. It's ridiculous! The only "revolutionary" games are the golf ones! Maybe that one tennis one too. It is sad how every game developer thinks his/her idea for an MMO hasn't been done before because it has a different name. I'd have to say the best MMORPGs are...
-Guild Wars, because its actually fun. And it's not just grinding. You always have some sort of quest that's not just "Go kill x amount of enemies."
... And that's about it!
Guild Wars got the basic system right. It's got its flaws sure, but at least its not just grinding. I've played a game, don't remember it's name, but it took me until level 6 or 7 to find my first quest. That's insane. Give me a tutorial or something. There are some promising ones coming out such as Aion whose gameplay looks quite fun. Albeit, the story looks just as generic as any, but oh well.
I'd have to say one game gets an "It was almost a good game". Mabinogi. It was different. you could go the entire game without fighting. (Well, sorta) However, it had one major flaw. To actually do the story quests, see most of the world, get the best weapon/armor, and a whole lot of other crap, you had to pay a monthly subscription! Damn you, Nexon! You ruined a great game. Adn that leads me onto my next order of business...
Cash shops. Either make me pay for a game, or make it free. A cash shop is one thing I despise more than anything. "Alright guys, we're gonna make a pretty decent game and it's gonna be free. So to pay for the server upkeep and whatnot, we will make a cash shop!" I guess it sounds smart... But, to me, it'd be a lot better to just make the people buy the damn game, and give it to them with no strings attached.
Well, I guess that ends my rant. I'm sorry, but I had to get my frustration out. Oh and one side note... "Dofus"? What the hell kinda name is that for an MMO?
Anyway... [/rant]