@Shadow- Lol, the fuck you would. Any man who says that is a lier~!
A sexual relationship: Fat girl/attractive girl. I don't care what their personalities are like, no man will pick a physically and noticeably ugly girl (no matter how you click) over a very attractive girl... We're talking about sex here, not "just being friends" with her.
It's basic evolution, personality is a distant second compared to beauty. You're subconsciously looking for a genetically superior mate, how you tell this is by what you find physically attractive.
If you pick the ugly girl over the attractive one, it's because you have a twisted sexual fetish for how that "ugly" girl looks. If given a choice, men will choose the mate that they find as the most attractive.
We're all slaves to evolution, not much can be done about it...