Feedback / Criticism / Suggestions

Sorted =)

I want a blue skin.
I know it's selfish but I love blue... And I'm sure Silverline can make a great blue skin.

I think the extra access badges should be a little less ... neon orange?
To me, it seems that part of the reason people are leaving is because they had been here for a long time and they weren't given EA. Maybe if there just wasn't any indicator, it'd be nicer. These things seem to scream "EXCLUSION!!!". Due to the fact the exclusion is not based on RM skill, I think that is what is leading people to believe that the forum is losing focus, at least to some degree. I also think a few of the boards in General could become Child boards in order to lessen the size of the General section. Like, Forum Games and ID could go in General Chat, Video Games in Entertainment, etc...

I dont know Modern_Algebra, when I first came back and saw some of you guys with EA Logo I figured you guys were the ones to go to if I had a problem because you guys were probably experienced users... so I think it was quite helpful for me.

Well, I'm not sure if they can accurately be used that way, since admission to EA is not based on RM skill.

Well, then I didnt really know what it meant but now I do. Im just saying since you guys are regulars you should no more than the average person. If you get what I mean.

I get what you mean.

Yet, I agree with modern_algebra's thought.
Honestly, the first reason I active at RMRK, is because I can enjoy everything.

I am not aiming for anything... but I can understand how people feel that they're not EA even though they have been active for a very looong time.

And EA is mostly like... for fun I think the way EA were chose are kind of... random.

I suggest that we rename the Tutorials forum to Tutorials and event systems
Tutorials and event systems often go hands in hands. The reason why I suggest this

Edit: <3

I think people who have been apart of this forum should get a badge as well.

I suggest that we rename the Tutorials forum to Tutorials and event systems
Tutorials and event systems often go hands in hands. The reason why I suggest this

Edit: <3

You're welcome. XD Jk. That was a good idea though. And  there's the extra access for that, one ray.

Extra Access is still very narrow in choosing, that's the problem oneray mentioned by his sentence.
I think.

What is extra access?

an extra section of the forum is shown to selected members. Members are not chosen based on RM skills.

Oh! So that is *cough*i am be extra *cough* extra access means. I am sure you will choose *cough* me *cough* wisely for this presitgous thing.

Yup.

Also: SILVERLINE, I BEG FOR SPELLCHECK.

Firefox has one built in =o

SMF supports spellchecking, though I'd have to install spellchecking software on my server for SMF to use =x

It just seems like a good idea.

And yeah, I know I have it, but I'm not one of the guys who needs it.

Any way to make it so people have a link to their wiki in their profiles? Or like, a wiki space where they just put the link in themselves if they have one?

Edit: And you know when someone posts you see the little buttons under their names (Email, yahoo ect) make a wiki button there too :*

That would take alot of effort =(

Maybe I could do it =p

thnk u =)

hmmm...I read in wiki about the guilds, how about bringing them back, yet have them for extra access and members, and they will compete, instead of just extra access? That would be fuuun! 

How about dividing the script forums in to four sections:

Script [The general script forum] (Smaller, simpler scripts should remain here)
Script Requests [under scripts] ('nuff said)
Script Database [under scripts] (Well made or useful scripts moved here)
Script Help [under scripts] (Should anyone get a script error or need help with RGSS, it should go here)

I think it would be better instead of script help, requests, and some ignored scripts in one forum.

I think that the RMRK Game Maker section title should be changed because it could be confusing to new members as well as moving it below RMRK RPG Maker to show that we put RM infront of GM.

GMRK Game Maker Resource Kit...

But I think there should be more sections in the Game Maker area.

Per se:

Tutorials or Resources.

The game maker section isn't a mirror of the rpg maker section because there's simply way, way less demand/usage of game maker.