Who has managed to tug at your heart strings, completely surprise you or keep you interested for hours with their storyline?
I find there are a lot of great story writers out there, and I haven't played through many of the GIAWs yet, so my nominations are likely incomplete, but I'd like to nominate:
joy, for Order of the Marten (http://rmrk.net/index.php/topic,31412.0.html)
blueperiod, for LINUS (http://rmrk.net/index.php/topic,33922.0.html)
Sailerius, for Vacant Sky (http://rmrk.net/index.php/topic,23712.0.html)
I wish I had more than three nominations.
NAMKCOR for Planeswalker's story. Many people can vouch for that one.
Reives yet again for Do You Remember My Lullaby?
Zylos has written the story for 2 of the games I've posted, Anima and Revenant, both of which were great successes (at least on Chaos Project). I'm also quite impressed by the prospect for his next game, so I nominate Zylos for Story as well.