Anyone know a good place that has reliable prices for selling Magic cards?
Your local hobby store
look up game store in the phone book.
I tried selling a few complete sets of Pokemon cards that I have. (I don't know why I have them, so don't ask) All the local hobby shops around here said that my best bet would be ebay or another online site. Nobody really plays trading card games anymore, and the people that do are an extremely niche crowd.